IBM Systems

Penn State-IBM Partnership Accelerates Search for Elusive Neutrinos

This post originally appeared on Penn State News

In the "Princess and the Pea" fairy tale, a young woman must prove her status as royalty by detecting whether a pea was placed under dozens of mattresses during her sleep. What if she used deep learning to detect that pea? That’s the approach taken by Doug Cowen, professor of physics and astronomy & astrophysics, and his research group, who are trying to detect nearly imperceptible particles, called neutrinos, arriving at the Earth from distant galaxies. Thanks to Penn State’s growing partnership with technology leader IBM, the Cowen group is now able to scale up their research to detect more neutrinos, helping to further improve our understanding of the cosmos.

A flaring supermassive black hole 3.7 billion light-years from Earth in the constellation Orion is the suspected source of a super-high-energy subatomic particle, a neutrino. Image: Nate Follmer/Penn State

The Princess and the Neutrino

If sensing a pea under a pile of mattresses sounds impossible, consider the task of detecting neutrinos. They are smaller than atoms, they don’t have a charge, they travel near the speed of light, they are nearly massless and, most importantly, they only interact with two of the four fundamental forces in the universe. These characteristics lead to a behavior that make them even harder to observe than a single vegetable seed — they pass directly through matter without leaving much of a trace. In fact, billions zing through us at every moment, unseen and unheard. Thought to be one of the most prevalent subatomic particle in the universe, neutrinos are created  during natural atomic decay processes, in supernovae, or from nuclear reactions in the cores of stars.

By better understanding how, when and why neutrinos from outside the Solar System arrive on Earth, scientists can paint a clearer picture of our universe’s history, and peek into the inner workings of processes such as nuclear fusion or supernovas. But before neutrinos can be studied, scientists need to develop a reliable way to detect them. 

The first neutrino was detected in a laboratory in the 1950s, but it wasn’t until 2018 that a high-energy neutrino from outside our solar system was first detected on Earth. That breakthrough came seven years after several hundred scientists got a sensitive detector up and running below the ice in the South Pole — the IceCube collaboration, funded by the National Science Foundation, of which Cowen and his team are members.
Buried deep under ice in the South Pole, IceCube is a sophisticated observatory that filters out background noise to isolate only the neutrinos that make it through layers and layers of ice. There, ultrasensitive photodetectors sense when a particle traveling near the speed of light emits faint amounts of bluish light known as Cherenkov radiation.

But because neutrinos are so prevalent, and many that we detect are created in the Earth's atmosphere, part of the challenge for the Cowen team is further sifting out the astrophysical neutrinos from those originating nearby.

Neutrinos by any other flavor

A highly reliable way to know if a neutrino comes from a distant cosmological event is to identify the type or “flavor” of neutrino — electron neutrino, muon neutrino, or tau neutrino.

Based on our understanding of the universe, Cowen said, tau neutrinos have a very high likelihood of originating from outer space and not from the Earth’s atmosphere.

“We’ve seen dozens of electron flavor and dozens of muon flavor neutrinos, but there has basically been, in history of mankind, only one or two astrophysical tau neutrinos detected — we want to double or triple that,” said Cowen. “The sample of these events is very, very small, and at present IceCube is the only experiment that can see them.”

Just as it’s incredibly difficult to detect a neutrino in the first place, knowing what type of subatomic particle is detected is a nearly insurmountable challenge.

“There’s a difference in the signature we see from certain flavors, particularly electron neutrinos and tau neutrinos at high energies,” said Aaron Fienberg, postdoctoral scholar in Cowen’s research group. “It’s very subtle, so it’s difficult to manually construct an algorithm to distinguish between them.”

Enter deep learning.

The team takes IceCube observational data and represents that as a two-dimensional image, much like a graph with data plotted on X and Y coordinates. Using a type of deep learning known as a convolutional neural network, the team is training a computer model to correctly identify what type of neutrino was detected based on the subtle signatures each flavor leaves. They train the model with “events,” or signatures made by different flavors of neutrinos detected by IceCube, and the model teaches itself what features of the images are most salient for classification.

“You can stare at these different events and manually separate them from the backgrounds, or you can feed the whole thing to the neural network and let the network do that heavy lifting for you,” Cowen said.

Two sample signatures produced by simulated data of a tau neutrino and an electron neutrino. Cowen's group uses deep learning to develop a model that can identify the flavor of neutrino based on the signature it produces. IMAGE: Doug Cowen/Penn State

Classifying images is where IBM’s support has furthered Cowen and his team’s goals.

For years, IBM and Penn State have strengthened a partnership. Since 2014, IBM has hired more than 50 full-time employees from Penn State’s alumni ranks, bringing the total to more than 175. IBM has also donated more than $1 million to Penn State since 2014 and is one of the University’s educational alliance partners. The partnership reached a new height in 2019, when IBM donated a cutting-edge system, known as the AC922, to Penn State, where it sits in a test environment of the University's supercomputer, ICDS-ACI, run by the Institute for Computational and Data Sciences. It’s the exact same hardware powering the world’s two biggest supercomputers, Summit and Sierra, both located in U.S. national laboratories.

For Cowen’s group, this hardware pays dividends. First, it sports a terabyte of memory, which is used for storing data temporarily while it gets processed.

“One of the nice things about having all that memory is that it makes it really easy to prototype new things without optimizing the code,” said Fienberg. “You can just play around without worrying about exhausting the resources, which is great for scientists. We’re not experts in software, necessarily.”

What’s more, the AC922 has cutting-edge graphics processing units (GPUs), which are built for rendering and processing graphics. The AC922 has four powerful GPUs, Nvidia V100s.

"The work we’re doing relies heavily on GPUs,” said Cowen.

Cowen said he initially had reservations with using the AC922 because it’s built using a different hardware architecture than where his group had run their code previously, and he wasn’t sure if the code they had written for another type of hardware would work.
IBM provided support to help Cowen’s team achieve their goals.

“We didn’t want to take a lot of time to get our code to work on the AC922 processors, but IBM stepped up and said, ‘We’ll help you do that,’” said Cowen.

IBM, with a team of dedicated research support staff, volunteered the time of one of its software engineers to troubleshoot any potential issues with running code on the AC922. Within days, Cowen said, IBM had gotten the code working, where it continues to run today.

“IBM is pleased to have been able to assist Dr.Cowen in this important research,” said Dave Turek, vice president, High Performance and Cognitive Computing, IBM. “The novel fast communications link between the GPUs and the CPU (NVLINK) on the AC922 has been critical in helping the research team at Penn State achieve the kind of superior processing performance observed. Modern scientific computing is highly dependent on being able to manage and move voluminous data at high speed and the AC922 was purposely designed with that goal in mind.

It’s a bird, it’s a plane, it’s — a supernova?

Already, Cowen said his team is processing images and data almost twice as fast as they were doing before using the GPUs and memory on the AC922.

Given the sparse number of tau neutrinos detected to date, increasing that by virtually any amount will have a significant impact on the neutrino physics community. The team plans to investigate several astrophysical research questions with the new data they can generate. They also hope to port their code over to IceCube computers at the South Pole so that the detector would act as an alert system to warn telescopes, which can follow up to confirm the distant source of the neutrinos, whether that’s from a neutron star, supernova or other cosmological event.

“Ultimately we hope to put this neural network that’s trained to identify tau neutrinos at the South Pole running in real time, where it could broadcast alerts to the astrophysical community to a network that’s already set up,” said Cowen. “This message would be broadcast out to all telescopes that are interested, on Earth and in orbit, to look to these possible sources of neutrinos.”